Business brokerages
How do I tell a serious business buyer from a tyre kicker?
A serious buyer can show you four things early: money to pay, a timeline, relevant experience and a clear reason for buying. Ask for them before you spend a call, score each enquiry on them, and let only the strong scores reach your calendar. Borderline scores are yours to judge, and the rest go to a slower track.
Harry Clancy, founder of Halcroft · Published
What separates a serious buyer from a tyre kicker?
A tyre kicker is interested. A serious buyer is able and ready. The difference shows up in four places: whether they can fund the purchase, whether they have a date in mind, whether they have bought, run or worked in something like the business, and whether they can say why they want to buy at all.
No single answer settles it. A buyer with strong funding and no timeline is a prospect, not a deal. A buyer with a firm timeline and vague funding is a risk. You are looking for the pattern across all four.
What should I ask before I give anyone a call?
Put the questions on the enquiry form or in the first reply, and keep them short. First, roughly what budget they are working to and how they expect to fund it. Second, when they would like to have bought by. Third, what they have done before that is relevant, whether that is running a business, working in the sector or buying a company. Fourth, why this kind of business and why now.
Asking for proof of funds at this stage can put off honest buyers, so it is usually better left to a later step. You want a stated position you can test on the call, not a document.
Free-text answers usually tell you more than tick boxes. A buyer who writes two clear sentences about why they want to own a business like yours has often done more than a tyre kicker is likely to.
How do I score an enquiry?
Picture a brokerage that scores each of the four areas 0, 1 or 2, where 0 is no answer, 1 is a partial answer and 2 is a clear one. That gives a total out of 8. Its rule, set in advance, is that 6 or more with no zero on funding or intent earns a call. A total of 3 to 5, or a high total with a zero on funding or intent, is borderline and the broker decides personally. Anything lower goes to the slower track. The thresholds are an example, so set your own.
A clear answer sounds specific. For example, on funding: "I am paying from savings plus a bank loan I have already discussed with my lender." On timeline: "I want to complete by spring." On experience: "I ran a similar service business for several years." On intent: "I want to own a business with repeat clients that I can run day to day." A partial answer is "I have some capital" or "soon". A zero is a blank or "just looking".
Decide the threshold in advance, not enquiry by enquiry, so a persuasive email does not talk you past your own rule. Weight funding and intent most heavily, which is why the example above gates a call on them: experience can often be learned and timelines tend to move, but a buyer who cannot fund the deal or cannot say why they want it is unlikely to complete.
Review the scores against outcomes after a few months. If your high scorers are not the ones reaching offers, change the weights. The score is a working guess and should be corrected by what actually happens.
What should I do with the buyers who score low?
Do not ignore low scorers, and do not give them a call yet. Put clear low scorers on a slower track: a short reply that says what you need to see, a place on the list for new instructions that suit their stated budget, and a check-in later. Borderline scores are different. Those you read yourself and decide case by case, often by replying with the missing question before deciding on a call. Some low scorers may come back with the missing detail, and those are worth a conversation.
This protects your time without burning a relationship. A buyer who is early today can be serious later, and a short, polite reply that holds off the call costs you very little.
Can this be automated, and where should a person stay in charge?
The collecting, scoring and routing can be automated, because it is the same sequence every time: capture the answers, apply your rule, send the strong ones to a booking link and the rest to the slower track. What should stay with a person is the rule itself, the judgement on borderline cases, and every conversation with a buyer you want to keep.
Separately, and unrelated to the scoring method above, a UK business brokerage reports 3x qualified discovery calls from a lead-qualification system. The figure is client-reported, not audited, and it describes that firm only. It is not a promised outcome, and what you see will depend on your enquiry mix and how well your own rule fits your buyers.
Common questions
A few more, answered briefly.
- Should I ask for proof of funds up front?
- Usually not. Ask how they expect to fund the purchase and test the answer on the call. Proof of funds usually belongs later, once both sides are serious.
- What if a good buyer writes a very short enquiry?
- Reply with the questions rather than rejecting them. A short enquiry is a thin signal, not a negative one, and the reply shows whether they will engage.
- How many questions is too many?
- Four short ones is enough to score on. Each extra question can lose some genuine buyers, so add one only if it changes who you would call.
- Does a score replace my judgement?
- No. It decides who gets the first call, not who gets the deal. Borderline scores are yours to judge, as is every buyer you take forward.